# Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité: On Governance and Evil *Created:* 2026-11-21, *Modified:* 2026-11-21 ![[Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité (cover).png]] ![The Value of Horrific Evils in TTRPGs](https://youtu.be/ynn4aZoL8oM) For a change, I have absolutely nothing negative to say about a video or other piece of media. [Chubby Funster](https://x.com/ChubbyFunsterGC) (CF) is absolutely correct on every point. 10 out of 10, no notes. I've got nothing to add to what he said within the context of what he said. It's amazing. In particular, his point that you need a horrible, ugly world in places to give the heroes something to look heroic against is critical if you want to tell a story about heroes. Of course, not *every* story is about *heroes*, and yet the advice still holds up. If your protagonists are anti-heroes, if they are criminals, if they *are* the shady motherfuckers, if they are out there doing the devil's business and business is good, you still need a world where scarcity and threat are significant in order for them to look like they are at least within their own rights doing the right thing. But how does this map to Enlightenment-era and later societies? After all, while the problem of scarcity is a long way from solved in much of the Western world, you can certainly consider it largely addressed, and yet there is still strife, there is still war, there is still violence, there is still struggle, there's tyranny and obligation. But we're no longer in a points of light world like classic **D&D** or **Dark Sun**. You shouldn't interpret "points of light" in this context as places of safety and comfort, but instead flickering lights holding off the darkness, which may be hard men with swords and blood in their eye, with torches raised high. The POL architecture is great for storytelling, and it actually translates very well into modern and space settings. But what if you're not in points of light? What if you have a tapestry of interconnected social groups[^1] where transport is comparatively cheap, communication is extremely cheap, and basic human needs are largely covered? Where does the conflict come from? Well, you could focus on class-based differentiation. That is largely the angle cyberpunk as a TRPG genre has come from. It *works* as long as your protagonists come from the bottom of the barrel. They have a feeling of oppression, they have fewer resources than they need, and they struggle to get more. In that context, it is very hard, but not impossible, to tell a story turned on its head where the protagonists are members of the corporate elite, or at least the corporate class. A good example of a game that pulls it off extremely well is called **[[MSG - The Deoffensified Edition|MSG™]]**, where the protagonists are grunt work at a major corporate entity in what is a half-dystopian cyberpunk world. (I say half-dystopian because in some way, somehow, cyberpunk dystopias seem to ignore the fact that you can't have major corporations who sell lots of products and foster a consumerist lifestyle if there's nobody that can actually afford to and has the leisure time to use those products. It's a hole in the cyberpunk philosophy that's always bothered me, but peripheral to the current conversation.) The player protagonists are tasked from above with directives to forward the cause of the company, but there is little concern about how they do it. Morality is, after all, the province of individuals, not of organizations. Now, the onus is on the players to figure out how they want to execute the will of their employers while maintaining their shreds of humanity or morality, if they ever had any. What then are they struggling against? It's not a scarcity of personal resources. They have no questions about eating and sleeping indoors. They're not particularly concerned about security matters unless the problem *they* have is a problem about security. Instead, their concerns are about a scarcity of reputation, a scarcity of personal autonomy, a scarcity of time, and a scarcity of trusted relationships. In an era of plenty, protagonists really need to be in a situation in which they are short of something to provide their motivation. If they're not, you get a lot of characters sitting around engaging in navel-gazing and very little interesting decision-making. Let's shift our gaze then to another science fiction property, **[[Traveller]]**, which I often like to talk about and really have adored as both a setting and a game loop since my youth. What is that essential game loop? You have a group of competent people who have experienced some portion of life, who then are given a ship, a debt, and a mandate to get out of the hole. How they do so then is entirely in their own hands, whether it be trading cargo from star system to star system and trying to stay out of as much imperial entanglement as possible, or selling their services as mercenaries, as killers, or as defenders, protectors, guards. They have a world of plenty, for the most part. There's no question that they can all earn enough money to eat and sleep indoors. The question is whether they can afford to pay for the most scarce resource in their purview: their autonomy and freedom, because this isn't slavery in the sense of being conquered and encompassed by a greater political entity. This is the deliberate debt taken on in order to purchase freedom of movement, freedom of choice, freedom of thought, and the freedom to say no. What drives the **Traveller** protagonist is, at its most base level, the willingness and desire to go out and make of themselves something more than they are, trading a debt up front for that autonomy and freedom of choice. Interestingly, the system generation of **Traveller** does lend itself to a certain degree of POL experience. As you explore, as you move throughout known and unknown space, you may find stretches where there are very few resources. There may not be any other people either. Yet there is the potential for knowledge, for exploration, for documentation, for scientific curiosity. If you want, you can always try to stand up to the Imperium, but good luck with that. That's really not a reasonable position to take. You can leave the Imperium, head out for the Rim. You can become criminals and exist within the Imperium as people seeking more freedom than the law will allow,[^2] but you're not going to topple it. It remains the figure that will stay at the top of the hierarchy and maintain that hierarchy for itself. Is it evil? Not necessarily. It's simply self-propagating. Whether it be an Imperial domain or a kingdom nestled against the mountains — maybe even a single walled city — what if your scale is smaller than an entire continent? What if you want your narrative to fit within a more reasonably scaled box? Less broad strokes, more dense detail. Well, nothing really changes about the analysis of what protagonists need, but the forces that they deal with certainly change. The characters may count coin as a resource that they're short of, but the far more important resources are social recognition and credit by the powers that be, whatever those powers may be: ruling houses, criminal families, gangs, guilds. Reputation with and between all of these can be the scarcity that drives entire campaigns, even if you never set foot outside of a city or a space station. CF is absolutely correct. Characters need "evils" in order to struggle against scarcity, seeking leverage to better their own position to defeat those evils. Those evils may or may not be actually morally evil by modern standards. They may or may not be evil by historical standards. But they do have to motivate the protagonists enough that they see them as an evil to be dealt with and overcome. In my sadly underplayed solo version of the **ShadowDark** scenario, which I've called **[[The Solofull Fane|SoloFane]]**, the protagonist is not a particularly good guy. His primary motivation is to pull off the biggest con the continent has ever seen, and as part of that, he wants to pass himself off as a sorcerer, a magus, someone with otherworldly wisdom, something that he very pointedly does not have. What is the evil against which he struggles? What is the scarcity that he contends with? Well, it is a late Iron Age world because I've embedded it in the **Ironsworn** context. Very much a part of a POL environment where danger extends in all directions between inhabited cities, towns, and villages. Resources such as food, water, shelter, and safety are all in short supply, especially for someone traveling. He does get assaulted by goblins on the way into the small village he's currently stuck at, but the other resource that he is short of is *"respect for his chosen role"*. He doesn't just want to pull off a con. He wants to be *known* to have pulled off a con after it's done. He wants the glory. The glory is in short supply, and seeking that glory is a motivation that can go a long way, because he regards *the universe's failure to acknowledge his talent as a great evil*. While it's not as impressive an evil as a *Sorcerer-King*, it still suffices to get a character moving and make them interesting. We've gone from science fiction to the Iron Age and talked about the necessity of scarcity and evil. That's a long way to go. There are a thousand bits I could have mentioned along the way here, but I'm interested in your ideas on evils and scarcity. What unusual resources have pushed characters forward in your game? Where have your characters found their evil? Let me know in the comments below, or just say hi, whatever. I'm curious. Call it my need to know. [^1]: Elsewhere in the garden, I use the word "factions" a whole lot to refer to these sorts of things. And technically, that's the proper term. Factions are just groups who interrelate and have their own agendas, if we're being minimalist about it. [^2]: ![The Dukes of Hazzard 1979 - 1985 Opening and Closing Theme](https://youtu.be/67gig0f4HLo) You're welcome. No, this isn't the first time that I've thought about recontextualizing **The Dukes of Hazzard** in a sci-fi game. There is at least some sort of predecessor: the third-party FitD game **[Copperhead County](https://zzzwizard.itch.io/copperhead)** at least takes some inspiration from the show, but just not enough. Plus it's not in space.