# Fair Warning Has Been Offered: A Review of Edge of Fate's Mythology
*Created:* 2026-11-20, *Modified:* 2026-11-20
![[Fair Warning Has Been Offered (cover).png]]
*Broken Tablet icon © Lorc / game-icons.net (CC BY 3.0)*

> @squidlord Hey. By all means ignore this cold tag if you want, but I wanted to reach out and ask for your thoughts and opinions on my lore.
> You're someone who's not afraid to say the truth and I understand the importance and value of it.

[@EdgeOfFateTTRPG](https://x.com/EdgeOfFateTTRPG) I haven't looked over there yet, but are you sure you want to open this particular Gaping Maw to the Abyss of Dark Criticism? I'm willing to do it, but I'd like people to know what they're getting into.

> @squidlord Absolutely I am! I want to create something good.
> So you know too depending (you might already answer them) on your answer, I would like to ask a couple more. It's just before asking those questions I want to know your opinion first.

All right, fair warning has been offered. I've opened it up in another tab, and I will go through it when I'm less disappointed with humanity, which will be[^1] tomorrow morning.
I won't say I'm a lot less disappointed in humanity in the morning, but I'm going to give it one more time over the last half century. Obviously, I don't learn from history.
---
All right, so now it's time to switch over and get the thread to which I wish to reply and put it over here. Luckily, I have tools for that.

> Reposting the lore of Edge of Fate that'll be in the corerule book so it's all in one thread.
> I want to ask a couple people a question and it's not cool having it all in separate threads.
>
> The lore is here in the comments "tagged" numerically in parentheses.
I appreciate this being broken down as it is. There's sort of an inherent block-by-block mechanism by which one can respond. I'm going to give comments as they come up in the blocks along the way, and then we'll get together and chew the fat about what I've read at the end.
It's the first thing in the morning after I've brushed my teeth and had a nice lunch, so I'm probably as welcoming as I'm ever going to be.

> (1) In a time before humans recorded history a demon broke through the boundary that separates our world from its own.
> Moving with hate and breathing deceit, for centuries it labored to confine mankind into suffering by blinding people from truth.
We start with a straight-up corruptive influence from an otherworld, which implies the *presence* of an otherworld. This is good. It gives a possible space beyond the known world to explore and to bring in elements to influence the narrative beyond just the corruption of the demon. (Adding this note after I've gone through the whole thing: this otherworld never comes up again and has absolutely no bearing on anything anywhere for any purpose.)
By the way, why is it called a demon and not something more obscure? Does it not have a name?
This could probably use some grounding.

> (2)Even the immortal idols, who influence the choices of those who pay peity too them, are intimidated by the demon. The idols, each wanting the favor of mankind and fearing the demons treachery and callousness, choose to avoid the demon when their paths cross.
Why are the idols intimidated by the demon? What can it do that they can't?
What is it willing to do that they can't? Why are the idols so intimidated that they are willing to forego the favor of mankind and not protect humanity?

> (3) As capable as the demon is, there were some that had the potential to kill it.
> The Magian.
> A race of humans who had a deep understanding of nature. Of life. Which provided to them the tongue of the language arts.
> A destructive force capable of immense power.
Okay, so we have an elder race of humanoid. How did they get a deep understanding of nature? Where are they from? How did they come to be?
Did the idols create them, or did they arise naturally from humanity in response to the threat of the demon? What is their relationship? Not only that, what is their connection to the people who are not Magian?
Are they at odds? Do they think they should be in charge? Are they subject to them? Are they staying hidden?

> (4) Being physically unable to speak the language and wanting to preserve its own life, the demon patiently and cunningly swayed the Magian from depending on this ability. From speaking incantations.
> Starting with infecting the world with a virus.
Why is the demon unable to speak the language? Why is the demon unable to learn the language?
Because in theory, there's written language as well, right? Or is there not? If there is not, we need to specify what era of human development we're talking about here.
If there is, we need to explain why the demon can't use that. How did the demon sway the Magian? You've just said that it doesn't speak the language, so what does speaking incantations do? Did it speak the virus into being?
Should it be referred to as a virus, or should it be referred to simply as "a disease"?
(Second pass noting here, but what I think is *meant* to be said is that the demon convinces the Magian that speaking incantations is infecting the world with a virus, a virus that the demon itself has created. I think that's what's intended to be said, but it would be nice if that were just what it did say.)

> (5) Not knowing what it was the Magian believed the demon when it expressed to them their use of magic has been slowly killing the planet.
So the demon is averting the Dark Sun possibility, which I find kind of hilarious, rather than ominous. But you just said that the demon doesn't speak the language of the Magian.
Is language itself an infection? Something happened in here that doesn't connect by cause and effect. So that needs to be fixed.
(I *think* that the implication here is that the demon caused the infection, and the demon's blaming it on magic. Simple, straightforward. Why didn't it get written that way in the first place?)

> (6) They believed it when it conveyed to them their use of magic is a consumption and was interfering with the cylce of life. That something must be given to sustain life, without a return the cycle ends.
All right, so the demon is counseling them that there is a conservation of energy within the cycles of life, and that sacrifices are necessary in order to provide power to the world in general. Very Aztec of it.
I approve of its approach.

> (7) The Magian loved the planet. They loved life and wanting to preserve it they chose to stop speaking the language arts.
Does this mean that they chose to stop speaking language in general, or that they chose to stop speaking the magical language that the demon taught them specifically? Because these are very different things and are going to bring up very different possibilities of outcome and reshape the setting as originally described.
If these creatures are mute outside of the use of demonic language, then they are a very different thing than a race of people who just didn't know the language used to invoke magic, which the demon taught them.
(Second pass notes: I'm pretty sure the intention is that they chose to stop using magic because the demon told them that it caused the virus. Though it would be kind of amusing if they just decided to give up spoken language altogether and concentrated on written language and sign language. Which would at least leave a lot more artifacts of mundane Magian writing behind.)

> (8) Learning from the demon, they built new homes with their hands. Ignited fire with flint. They walked for their water and tended their gardens with sweat. This new hard labor gave the Magian sweet sleep and in their deep slumber it attacked.
All right, now we're getting some information about when this myth is set in relation to human development. We are talking Stone Age, but you just said that the Magian loved life and so gave up speaking the language arts and then proceeded to make homes, ignite fire with flint, and engage in basic technological development.
Did they do so silently? Because that's going to seriously retard their development. Seems like the sort of thing that you ought to say.

> (9) Killing whole communities one at a time then disguising each one as a result of the world virus.
One assumes it's the demon doing the killing here. It needs to be strongly specified who's doing the killing and how it's disguised as the result of the world virus.
What I think you mean to say here is that entire communities were wiped out due to the world virus; the demon could direct it because it created the virus. Otherwise, this just doesn't make much sense, given that you literally just told us the demon created the virus in the first place.
Or does the virus not exist at all, and it was purely the machinations of the demon directly causing the problem in the first place?

> (10) The slow and methodical strategy gave time for the Magian to communicate with other settlements of the tragedies they found when seeing for themselves the aftermath. Convincing them further this plague was born from them.
What other settlements? The only group of people you've mentioned is the Magian.
You haven't even suggested that others existed, except for the fact that you implied it very indirectly by saying that the Magian were the ones that could oppose the demon.
It's a perfectly valid reading of what you wrote to say that the Magian are humans. So if there are other humans who aren't Magian, they need to be introduced into the myth well before this point.
Who are they convincing that the plague was born from whom? You've got two very vague pronoun pointers there, and on this of all points, you should not be vague. Are they convincing the other human tribes — either accidentally or intentionally — that the Magian are responsible for the viral outbreaks, or are they convincing themselves? Again, a vastly different and important interpretation that doesn't need to be vague.

> (11) Being consumed by these events, for many years, triggered the beginning of recording history for future generations.
Why? Why does this lead to the beginning of organized histories, and one assumes writing?
What about this provides a motivation and inclination to humanity to record things for the future? Where are they recording it? Is there a central library or scriptorium, where they intend to preserve the records? Is it every little tribe beginning to write down their own histories as they receive them?
Who, what, where, when, how, why? It's not just for journalism; it's for worldbuilding.

> (12) Believing they were all going to die and as a result of using the language arts, the Magian saved their culture through writings to be passed to others. Omitting the words that can speak powers into existence.
Which language arts do you mean, the language of magic? Because they were clearly writing down something else.
So there you go. What you mean to say here is, I think, the Magian also recorded their histories in the language of the human peoples, but left out of their histories the language of magic, making sure that the only people that have it are the people that already know it, and that it dies with them.

> (13) A heavy cloud of despair spread faster among the Magian then the demon, preparing them for the demons approach.
> Though not all were fully convinced, still questioning the demons motives before it arrived.
This doesn't make any sense. Why?
What is happening to make it occur? Is the demon spreading despair among the Magian? If so, how is it doing so, by what methods?
Secret whispers in the right ears? Wars and rumors of wars? Pressing the plague upon the borders of their lands, both as a warning and as a terror weapon?
Things are being done, but not by anyone. When you remove the agency of characters and organizations in your worldbuilding, you remove any reason to care about them.

> (14) Holding on to the possibility using magic wasn't the catalyst for the world virus.
Well, technically it was *literally* the catalyst for the world virus, or so you told us several paragraphs ago when you said that the demon created the world virus in order to help control the Magian and give them reason to abandon magic. So who is it that is holding onto the possibility that using magic wasn't the catalyst for the world virus and that the demon was lying? If we've got a faction, they need a name and intention and how they differ from everybody else and who they are and why they are.

> (15) In their records carefully placed words were scattered.
> Vestiges in hope of a revival.
> Few families tried to bring others with them into lands far away, but their surety wouldn't budge.
In whose records? The Magian's records?
I thought you said that they weren't going to preserve the words of magic. Which is it?
Which families are trying to bring others with them? Where are these lands far away: in other dimensions, on the other side of the world, on other planets?
Who won't budge? The people who were strictly desirous of staying in their homelands?
Entire families or individuals?
This situation is entirely too vague, and as such, you cut out the heart of making it matter to people.

> (16) Guilt pulled their eyes from seeing with discernment and in time the destruction of the last settlement was the end of the era of magic.
Guilt pulled whose eyes? The remaining Magian?
Well, it can't possibly be them because it was their settlements that had access to magical language.
I think this is you trying to phrase things in too high-minded and mythic a way and losing the ability to actually say what's happening. Theoretically, this would be important.
Are you saying that guilt over feeling responsible for the world virus kept the Magian from taking proper precautions and protecting their own settlements until the Magian were essentially wiped out as a people? Because if so, you should just say that.

> (17) When fuedalism gave rise and mankind without magic spread through the planet.
When feudalism gave rise to what? That's not even a proper sentence fragment. That's an incomplete thought.
It's an attempt at a temporal transition, but it's a clumsy and sloppy one. What you really mean is something like "In a thousand years, as feudalism rose among humanity, even without magic, they spread across the planet."
See how much cleaner that is and how much more direct?

> (18) The demon still scoured for remaining Magian who hid from the demon. Knowing it must be free from their potential to survive unmatched and through faint rumors and rare tellings of the language arts being used the demon concluded at least one survived.
Are you saying that there is one Magian who survived? Just the one, not a small family, not a small clan, not individuals dispersed throughout the human nations and trying to pass on their knowledge and family names? Just the one, a thousand years later.
Again, the language in this block is just next door to word salad, and it needs to be seriously cleaned up. I don't think it even knows what it wants to say.
What I *think* it says is, "The demon, wanting to reign unchallenged, thought there was one Magian who survived because of rumors and tales of the use of magic words."
Again, simple, clean, direct. Much better world-building.

> (19) To its disappointment one did survive. One Magian did out live those who fled and grew in unknown lands. One Magian searched the records of their history and learned the language arts.
It's been quite a long time. How long has that Magian been growing?
How did the Magian find the records of their history and find the language arts, given that the Magian themselves were very clear about trying to eradicate records of the language arts?
Who was it that recorded the thing that they absolutely did not want recorded because they thought it was going to destroy the world? Where did they record it? Why did they record it?

> (20) Deepening her understanding of life and finding its pulse this woman found depths no other Magian has explored. Never to return whole, but transcended through the folds of life and now stands through the door of time.
How did any of this happen, and why did it happen? Even taken purely as myth and legend, this cuts out one of the most important parts of magical mythology.
It takes work. Described like this, it's boring. It doesn't matter that she found some old documentation.
Apparently, all she needed was to deepen her understanding of life and find its pulse, and that let her do things that nobody else had ever done, despite having an entire society that was devoted to understanding those powers before the demon showed up.
What does it mean to transcend through the folds of life and stand before the door of time? Did she enter the vagina of the universe and now stand face to face with the clitoris?
What's going on?

> (21) Today she is known as the Ancient witch.
> The demon has learned of the Ancient witch and is afraid of her.
> The Ancient witch knows about the demon, but cannot find it.
"The ancient witch" is such a letdown. I can't even express how sad it makes me.
You have the entirety of human language to look at and model things on. You have constructed languages by the dozens.
You couldn't come up with an actual name for this character? A title? Something more than the most bland possible description, "The ancient witch"?
Why is the demon afraid of her? I thought the demon was out there wreaking havoc and having a good time. What is it doing? What has it been doing this whole time?
The ancient witch knows about the demon and has magic universe vagina powers but can't find the demon. Why?
Has it stopped actually doing things to go underground into hiding? Then why bother hunting it? It's not doing anything.
Why isn't the demon trying to hunt her and build up forces actively to do so with?
The story has stopped being about people doing things and switched entirely over to people avoiding doing things.

> (22) Still prowling with hateful intentions and knowing that pain breeds more pain, the demon continues to hardened the hearts of man to believe they are more worthy than others.
What is it doing to harden the hearts of man, other than walking to and fro in the earth? What is it actually doing out there?
Describe what it's up to, where it's at, how it moves, what the whole point of its plan is. What does it want?

> (23) Such as convincing the boy to steal his neighbor's chicken eggs and the young girl to flatter the stranger.
> Convincing the man to possess is a conquest and that ownership is a rank not to medle with.
> Convincing the woman that her opinion is true and no one else's matter.
It has all the ambition of a sixth grader. Great.
In a world after the rise of feudalism where statesmen, kings, jarls, and other powerful men and women hold the reins of power. An incredible demon capable of teaching mankind the language of magic, or persuading them not to use it, is spending its time convincing boys to steal their neighbor's eggs and telling men that they deserve to keep what they earn.
I've got to say, I think this is the worst fall since the demon apparently stumbled into our universe in a drunken haze. This is what it's up to, huh?
No grand schemes, no words in the ear of the worthy, no creating beliefs that are pursued zealously by the humans who adhere to them. No, I think you should go steal those eggs.
We've gone from the mythic to the mundane, and not in a good way.

> (24) The era of man's ways has established itself in a world infected with a virus. Pride in their hearts. Greed clothed their hands and lust blinded their eyes.
> Though not all desires bore despair.
Is the problem man's ways or the demon's ways? If it's man's ways, the demon really doesn't have to do anything.
The demon isn't really a corruptive influence if man is inherently corrupt. If it's the demon's ways, then the nature of man is to live free of corruption, and the demon has to take active steps to maintain the corruption, which leads back to the previous question.

> (25) The era of man's ways shown that some paths were available for great joys. For hope. To love.
Like what? I assume not stealing eggs. How is this a path? What is a path in this twisted terminology?
I think we're going to need a glossary of foolishness to deal with this.

> (26) Some paths changed entire directions of history.
> With the death of the Magian people began leaving the ways of living under fuedalism to seek out relics and treasures used and left behind by the Magian. Clothes, weapons, armor, artifacts, all imbued with magical attributes.
Why would people move beyond feudalism when the Magian died? The Magian were just one people.
They weren't even a ruling caste or a dominating population, according to previous descriptions. Maybe they should have been, but not as described.
They certainly didn't establish feudalism for all of humanity or even their local continent.
Is this one of those situations where we get to say, "Writers have no context for space, size, or time"? It comes up a lot.
Also, what does feudalism have to do with going out treasure hunting? Feudalism is a mechanism for managing and maintaining property and tax rights — going out and treasure hunting, looking for goodies, is something that definitely fits into feudal lifestyles.
I'm not sure if this is just dumb or uneducated. I can't tell.
You've got to help me here.

> (27) Venturing a new course for mankind.
What's the new course for mankind? Nothing here is a change. If anything, it is pretty much the status quo.

> (28)
>
> That's it!
>
> Please, let me know what you think. Don't be shy giving the cold hard truth.
> Any compliments, constructive criticism and comments help!
Okay, I've made it to the end, and the cold truth is: I think it's boring. It wants to reach for the mythic and can't seem to grasp the language or the concepts of mythology.
It doesn't work as a discussion of how man evolved through the ages in the presence of the demon. The demon itself really doesn't seem to do much after the initial contact. What does it want? What is it trying to achieve?
It realizes that the Magian have incredible magic power when it arrives, which it rightly perceives as a threat, and then it convinces them that magical power is going to destroy the world. So the Magian themselves go out of their way to begin eradicating records of their magic.
Did they not do a good job of it, despite the fact that they had magic to help them do so? Did they have a splinter faction that disagreed with the belief that magic was going to destroy and corrupt the world, and worked in secret to record true histories and tomes of magic?
So the Magian get essentially wiped out by their own choice and removed the records of them from the world themselves, all except for one woman who lives that long—especially if she needs to go find the cache of secret magic books left by Magian who destroyed all their magic books? Does that make sense to you?
We've moved from the early Stone Age all the way up into the feudal era. Now people are going to plunder the Magian settlements, which I assume were wiped out by the world plague? Why weren't they doing this before? They've had literal thousands of years to do this. Why would they just start now?
Basically, this doesn't hold together as a single narrative, not even as a mythic narrative, which allows for a lot of flexibility. It's not good, is what I'm saying. I don't want to have to say it, but that's what I'm saying.
It's a long way to go to justify the most bare-bones dungeon-diving excuse. It doesn't even give flavor to the things that the players are likely to encounter along the way. There are no actual forces pitted against one another. There are no factions, other than the demon and everybody else. This isn't a world. It's not even a myth.
I'm going to have to send you back to the blackboard to wipe it all off and start over from the top. There are a few fragments of good ideas in there, and then there's the rest. I'm sorry. That's just the way it is.
[^1]: And now "is."