# All That Is Beauty Is Not Pretension *Created:* 2026-11-14, *Modified:* 2026-11-14 ![[All That Is Beauty Is Not Pretension (cover).png]] *Amphora icon © Delapouite / game-icons.net (CC BY 3.0)* For those who have been here before, there is [[Collections/What IS Storygaming|a significant thread of back-and-forth articles written with Spyder regarding the core question of "What is storygaming?"]]. There are four articles in that collection, and I encourage you to read all of them, including the things to which they reply. It really doesn't have anything to do with *this* article, but it's good stuff. So make that a note to yourself to do later. Today we're going to deal with a new article, and I know what you're thinking. You're expecting this to go on for 20 or 30,000 words as I try and overexplain things to people who don't need it. That would be a fair expectation. You're right, apparently. But this does deserve some kind of response. So before you get into me, go check out Spyder's article over at: **[Responding to Beauty: Beautiful Games are Done on Purpose](https://allthethings123.blogspot.com/2026/11/responding-to-beauty-beautiful-games.html)**. ## The Crowned Self There are two parts to Spyder's article. In the first he goes on at great length about his personal philosophies, beliefs, and life, what he finds beautiful, what he finds interesting, and at a personal level, what he believes the world should be, then he focuses on what he believes role-playing game design not only does hinge on, but more importantly, *should* hinge on. I have a quite short and specific response to that. It's pretentious fucking twaddle. Not only that, it's self-indulgent pretentious fucking twaddle. That's James Gunn shit right there. That's someone who thinks that they stand equal to, if not in front of, their work, and that that's the way it should be. If not, the article wouldn't exist. It's interesting insofar as it reveals an inherent limitation of his imagination, one that he has turned from hindrance to nobility simply by coronation. Yes, I know how harsh that sounds, and it is exactly as harsh as I mean it. But worse than the absolute pretension and the inability to get away from one's ego in evaluating the world outside, there is the assumption that the landscape of the self should mirror another's landscape of the self, even in the face of clear evidence that they do not. The inability to model and imagine someone who thinks differently than yourself is arguably one of the great tenets of religion in general, and explains why they exist. In this case, providing a demonstration is better than a thousand liturgies. > Before someone points to the innumerable and insufferable “Christian” games made: stop. Memorizing Scripture for gameplay doesn’t count. Saying something is based off of older stories doesn't mean anything, because unless you're actually talking in ludonarrative, you're just blowing smoke. > > Before you say "Yeah I know a game that does that," you need to ask yourself, and you have to answer it honestly: > >> Did that beautiful experience at the table happen to you because everyone was pushing for it, or did the mechanics make it so easy it was almost inevitable? This is right underneath a specific explanation of how Spyder sees beauty and a particular *kind* of description of beauty, one that is extremely grounded in his own experience. He then flips to RPGs and pulls in one of the greatest Texas switches[^1] I've seen in the last 13 minutes. He goes from explaining his personal vision of God, heaven, and beauty to asking if there are Christian games that reach for those elements that he considers intimately necessary for the process of life. He then ties that vision into something that I find almost offensive, almost because it would have to actually have an element of truth rather than an element of ignorance for me to really get huffy over. *"Did that beautiful experience at the table happen to you because everyone was pushing for it, or did the mechanics make it so easy it was almost inevitable?"* Neither, dumbass. The experience happened because everyone at the table wasn't pushing for it, but they were receptive to it. They were ready to experience it. That happens not because the mechanics make it easy, or so easy it's almost inevitable, but because a number of things came to pass. Crucially, the mechanics *didn't get in the way of it*. At least one player saw the vision coming and wanted to share it with everybody else. Everybody at the table felt that it was okay to have that response. Note how very little of that has to do with mechanics. How much of it has to do with mechanics getting out of the way and letting players do what players do? When you focus on mechanics, *"making it so easy it's inevitable,"* what you're really talking about is forcing things to go your way as a writer and creator who has nothing to do with the players at the table, what they do, how they experience one another, what they want, or what they've been through. You have arrogated to yourself the idea of what they should be doing, and not facilitated their ability to do what they *want* to be doing. ## You're Gone This is a pretty critical rift between Spyder's philosophy of game design and my own. I don't think that games should force you to play any particular way. They should provide you the tools that you want to play how you want, and the selection of game by the players is the only communication from player to creator regarding what they want. But *you can't possibly hear that* because you are long gone by that point as a creator. The product is out there. It's doing its thing. The players are out there. They're doing their thing. You're gone. Now, if you want to demand a seat at the table, you've already screwed up. If you want to demand a seat at the table based on the fact that your vision of beauty is somehow superior to all other visions of beauty because it's yours and it speaks to you, well, people of my lineage have a well-worn linguistic construct which is often deployed in this situation: Fuck you. Fuck right the fuck off. > Meeting beauty and goodness to receive truth is the work of any sane human being. And we have those methods. > > So why the hell aren't we doing it??? ## Playing God After a lengthy discussion of the fact that there are various theories about how neurolinguistic programming and exposure to fiction and meditation can change how human consciousness functions, we get this beauty of a nugget. It's bullshit, of course. It's pretentious bullshit, which is worse, but it also reveals simultaneously stupidity and overweening arrogance, which I would normally appreciate in the quantities being displayed, but frankly, I expect better. Why do we as game designers not employ psychologically subversive methods to condition other people? To do, to think, to will as we act, to harmonize their idea of beauty and joy with whatever it is that we feel like it is this week? Why do we not arrogate the responsibility for their understanding and their enjoyment of life onto ourselves? I don't know. Usually when I want to play God, I have games for that. I don't have to actually play God and think that I know better than other people just because I have some qualified idea of beauty. Let's talk about that qualified idea of beauty while we're at it. ## The Taint I don't know where anybody gets off talking about what OSR is based on, getting to wargames, and then having the sheer unmitigated gall to say that wargames, and specifically the Prussian form of wargames as they are passed down to us, are neither beautiful nor good. This is a case of the author standing in front of the work, like the traditional picture of the woman who takes a picture of the Eiffel Tower and has to make sure that her face is in three-quarters of the frame. It is absolutely a failure of understanding of context and the ability to model other people. You know what? I find wargames beautiful. I find the entire lineage of wargames beautiful, whether it be **Kriegsspiel** or its descendants. I find **Chainmail** beautiful in its way. I find **Team Yankee** beautiful. I find **BattleTech** beautiful. Spyder would have you think that these things carry an inherent taint, and that everyone who looks upon the works of the mighty (wargame smiths) should despair because they inherit from a history motivated by one thing and one thing only: killing. That *to kill, your soul must be destroyed first.* This throws out 90% of everything that the Crusaders, who considered themselves the holiest of men, said about war and their own experiences, about why it was waged and how they felt about it, about how they felt that they were executing the holy will of Almighty God righteously, justly, and yes, beautifully. The Bayeux Tapestry itself is a work of beauty that meditates on the acts of war. Basically, I'm just saying this is kind of retarded and you could do better as a basis for argument. It is essentially undercutting his own argument using his own history, which is only a few paragraphs up in the page. The Holy Knights of Charlemagne remain unamused and unenthused. Is it easy to create great works of beauty within games inherited from a long history of military modeling with the intent of wreaking death, destruction, and pain upon your enemies? I believe everyone in the audience who isn't a pussy will say, *"Fuck yeah!"* There is a beauty in executing a proper pincer movement. There is a heart-deep joy that comes from seeing your enemy across the table fall into your trap. There is the simple satisfaction of watching things perform to your own intent and will. I think if you are playing a game, no matter what its underlying mechanical birth originated at, beauty is not just an occasional thing. I think beauty is inevitable, that you can't keep from experiencing beauty. ## An Empty Bucket I think beauty is everywhere that you look for it, and most places you don't, and that most tabletop TRPGs are turning up beauty left and right, in the experiences that the players have, without intending to, because that beauty cannot be injected. It can only be discovered, and it can only be discovered by the players who are playing it, and not necessarily intentionally brought by the creators. This actually loops back to help explain why ostensibly Christian, philosophically created RPGs suck so much. I'm going to be honest with you, because I have no reason to hold back. They suck balls and then gargle with the sweat. They are terrible. **[DragonRaid](https://lightraiders.com/)** is not a game I would wish on other people. None of the rest are particularly good either, and it's all largely around the same mistake in understanding. It's the belief that you can make people find what you think is beautiful beautiful. You have to point your finger at the most beautiful thing you can find on the table. But unfortunately, because you're the creator of a game, the only thing you can find to point your finger at *is the game*. You can't point it at the players because you don't know the players. You can't point it at the world because even though you *wrote* the setting, the GM embodies the setting. You are carrying water with an empty bucket, and when you get to the village, you can't watch the faces of the villagers light up as they receive your pure and untrammeled, unpolluted revelation from God. You showed up with an empty bucket. The Greeks had a really good word for this: *hubris*. Hubris (ὕβρις) was never the Greek word for pride. In Athenian law it was a charge you could bring against a man who treated someone else's honor as property to spend, and Aristotle's definition is the one that sticks: harm done for no gain beyond the pleasure of being above the person you are harming. The tragedians used it for the wider version — the mortal who picks up a prerogative that belongs to the gods and acts as though the ordering of the world were his to arrange. Hubris is a claim on something that isn't yours. Every moment of beauty that you come to in an RPG was easy to get at. It just required paying attention to the players at the table, which the creator cannot truly do. ## Stay Out of the Way As I alluded to earlier, the one thing they can do is simply try to stay the fuck out of the way. Every time you get in the way, you push beauty and joy further away, whether the game is first edition **D&D** or the most cutting-edge experimental diceless, GM-less, structureless game being played in Jeepform in Sweden in a tenement basement right now. All of this goes back to arrogance and the inability to imagine that other people experience beauty and joy in different ways and for different reasons. If anything is a deadly toxin for being a good game designer, it is, ironically, the inability to play a role that is not yourself. This incapacity is something I run into a lot more often in TRPGs than I ever thought that I would, and yet here we are. It comes up in players who will only play a singular character that never changes, one based on themselves, and it comes up with GMs who can't imagine a world different than the one that they see in their head. Every day, and it comes from creators, authors, game designers who believe that forcing their view of reality, either how it is or how it should be, onto a group of strangers is their highest calling. They are evangelists of the lowest order. I have little patience for evangelists. ## Six-Mile Dome But then, unfortunately for all of us, Spyder gets around to storygamers, as we knew he would eventually. Again, he engages in that lifelong pursuit, which we have seen illustrated elsewhere and before, of projecting like a Zeiss planetarium projector on a six-mile dome. He immediately goes on to say that most storygames are designed by raging Marxists, and because they don't share his philosophy on life, that they have no concept of beauty and instead can only see things through the lens of power. > Don't get uppity, storygamers > you're not any better. Most storygame design is reactionary against the ugly Prussian design that is at the heart of the OSR. And most of the people who are designing these games are, to be kind, damn fool idiot Marxists. And they don't believe in beauty, just power, by obviously. So instead of saying the obvious: > >> This game's mechanics are ugly. I should go for beauty. > > They instead say: > >> This game's mechanics don't play with power in a way I like. So says the man who has ranted at length in the same article about the fact that power is available to shape minds, and not only is it good to use it, but *should* be used — but only by people who agree with him, obviously. Otherwise, they might be Marxists or Objectivists or recidivists or seditionists, or I'm sure we can come up with some other groups that would probably be undesirable to be allowed to hold the reins of language. I've spent a lot of time with people on the storygaming side of the house, and I have my own complaints. I would say that quite a number of them are occupied by Marxist political philosophies to the detriment of themselves and their games, in direct mockery of the fact that they keep trying to sell us shit. But that isn't what's being described here. This is Spyder projecting his own actions and choices onto a group he doesn't like who ended up in a different place in terms of game design. That's because he is unable to imagine someone else finding beauty in a way he does not. This is one of many examples of a failure to imagine. So instead of listening to what they say, which does occasionally involve *"This game's mechanics are ugly, I should go for beauty,"* he interprets whatever is said in the way that reflects how he thinks they're said. *"This game's mechanics don't play with power in a way I like."* This after saying that designers should seek beauty and design their games to reflect that beauty. Perhaps this will come as a shock: most people find the way power is distributed unbeautiful. They find it ugly. They find it uncompassionate. They find it distasteful. They find it repulsive. Instead, they want to manifest their idea of beauty through their design of their mechanics. I'm pretty sure somebody was suggesting that others do that mere paragraphs ago. Perhaps I misread. No, the words are still there. They still say the same thing. This is just hypocrisy. Having now made the straw man stick a broom up its ass, Spyder reviles it, to suggest that approach is *damning*. Sure, no one actually said that that was the reason they made their game, and sure, it's entirely made up by him so he could set it on fire and dance around it like a maypole, and with much the same result after its fashion. He proceeds to give us a lecture on the purposes of power and what it should be put toward, what stories should be told about it, what stories should not be told by omission. We're being instructed, after all. It's our job to be good little sheep and listen when our betters speak to us. Maybe he *is* speaking from his revelation of liturgical enlightenment. Perhaps he *is* embodying the spirit of the Christian in his communication. I've long said that when people tell you who they are, you listen. If you can only speak about power in the way they want you to, then they don't want *you* to talk about power. When they say that you can only talk about, or *should* only talk about, beauty in the way they experience it, then they don't want *you* to seek after your own beauty. All you have to do is listen to people. They'll tell you what they think and what they believe, and if you watch what they do, they'll even tell you who they are. ## Above the Text I would say that most game designers never learn that trying to push an ideological architecture is a lot less interesting than providing things for other people to look at and come to their own conclusions. If you have a predetermined outcome in your mind, you've already failed. If you have an intent, that can be fine, but if the players refuse to read your script because it doesn't resonate with them, you've wasted your time and theirs. If the thing that you've made only works for people who believe what you do, and in order to make it work, the game design is intended to change what they believe until it's like what you believe, then you're doing something with RPGs that I can't really countenance, and I can't really support. You've degraded them. You've eroded the whole point of playing games. You have decided to put yourself above the text. You've put yourself above the game. You've put yourself above the people playing the game. You've failed at that most important of things, which is to realize a message all too often forgotten by Christians, and certainly by those who have experienced a painful epiphany. The thing that's been forgotten is humility. An obsession with power and how others want to talk about it points a finger directly at a loss of humility. *"I believe I can make you see beauty. Here are the techniques. Here are the methods. I think if you're not trying to make other people see beauty, you have failed in doing what is just and right."* That's what we're being told. That is what we have in front of us. In the closing, the hubris and the lack of humility reach their crescendo, as well it should. Claude Frollo would be thrilled.[^2] > **The pursuit of beauty and goodness for truth** > is the foundation of all human activities. That should be especially trust of gaming, especially TTRPGs. However, we've gotten caught up in the legacy of one of the most awful parts of the 20th century (ask yourself what the people making those wargames were a part of, and ask yourself if you're really any stronger than them), and ask: > > "Do my methods of gaming match the proven methods of finding the beautiful, the good, and the true? And, if not, can we somehow make something that does?" > Obviously, if you don't believe in the beautiful to begin with, you'll scoff. > > But the rest of us with common sense should walk away thoughtful. I will leave the lingering strains of *Hellfire* floating in the air for a moment of contemplation. You again are being instructed. You are being told you are being specifically driven and told what you should be doing in your games and why you should be doing them, in your entertainment, in your joy, in the time you spend with your friends, in the moments you spend with your family, in those wee hours of the morning when you're playing a solo game, and playing with ideas, experiences, and things that you would not experience in your day-to-day life. You are told explicitly what you should be doing. You should be pursuing beauty and goodness and truth. Enjoyment is debauchery and beneath you. You shouldn't be exploring ideas that are deliberately ugly in order to see new ways of finding beauty, or discovering that beauty is in places that you would never look because they're ugly. You should be obsessed, driven to avoid even the appearance of *"evil"* in the form of that which is unbeautiful. ## The Language of My People Again, I must return to the language of my people, that of the Appalachian hill people of northern Georgia, men and women who have lived among privation, suffering, and discrimination since before the Civil War. Many of their lineages go back to Ireland and Scotland, where they were justly imprisoned or not, and exiled to this new world as part of a prison colony, or debtor's colony, or sometimes just ahead of the reach of the law. Families who have come through the worst of life and history and now live quiet lives and share their time with one another, sometimes telling stories of those bygone days, which in and of themselves are not beautiful. Sometimes the stories reveal the *absence* of beauty and goodness in places where you might expect it. But they are often a taciturn people, people of few words. When presented with something like this, their genetic heritage screams in me. It demands response, and that response is: **Oh, fuck off.** Get off your pretentious twaddle bullshit high, with your pretense of appeal to Christianity, your actual appeal to authority that doesn't exist, and your arrogance of command. I have no problem talking about how games can represent beauty and truth of various sorts. I have no problem with someone saying, *"Here, this is the kind of game I want to create. How can I do that?"* All these are wonderful things. They're part and parcel of our world. That's not how it's been done here, nor is it the takeaway anyone could carry hints. It's an empty bucket, one predicated on the assumption that the person carrying it knows better than the thirsty villagers what they should be drinking anyway. You can fuck all the way off with that bullshit. [^1]: A Texas switch is a film trick: one actor is swapped for another mid-shot, usually so a stunt performer can take over, with no cut to hide it. You see the verbal equivalent of that all the time. This is a fine example. [^2]: ![Hellfire - The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1996)](https://youtu.be/gqGL9B_TPTI) If you're going to bring up Notre Dame, there are repercussions.